01 / Supplier comparison
Example brief: an industrial terminal, first order of 2,000 units, with defined functional tests. Candidates are compared on the same revision and scope before a recommendation.
| Decision factor | Candidate A | Candidate B | Evidence needed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Relevant process experience | Related terminal assembly | Related controller assembly | Comparable build records and process route |
| Quoted scope | Test fixture excluded | Test fixture included, software scope unclear | Normalize fixture, software and test responsibilities |
| Production commitment | 30 days after material readiness | 40 days after sample approval | Align start condition and verify bottleneck load |
| Next step | Review test preparation and available capacity | Clarify software scope and pilot plan | Do not rank candidates on unit price alone |
02 / Bottleneck capacity calculation
Assume an illustrative functional test takes 8 minutes per unit per station, including handling. Two stations are available. Scheduled time is 480 minutes per station per day, with an 85% effective-time factor and 95% first-pass yield.
2 × 480 × 85% ÷ 8 × 95%
≈ 97 first-pass good units / day
Across 20 production days: approximately 1,938 units before allowing for other committed work or additional losses. Against a 2,000-unit requirement, this scenario does not establish adequate capacity.
Verify actual station occupancy, repeat-test load and measured cycle time. Qualify additional resources or agree a revised delivery plan before committing the full order.
This simplified model is a screening scenario. Effective-time and yield definitions must be aligned to avoid double counting losses. Actual assessment requires product-matched observations and records.
03 / Production readiness gate
| Gate | Required evidence | Example status | Release condition |
|---|---|---|---|
| BOM & revision | Approved BOM, drawings and substitution record | Open: alternate component pending | Buyer design authority confirms the substitution |
| Test preparation | Qualified fixture, approved software and test records | Open: second fixture not qualified | Demonstrate repeatable results on each fixture |
| Pilot build | Yield, defect analysis and rework records | Trial not yet completed | Agree acceptance criteria and close critical findings |
| Material readiness | Stock verification and confirmed key-part arrivals | Partially evidenced | Confirm delivery dates and impact of shortages |
04 / Corrective-action register
| Finding | Priority & impact | Owner / timing | Closure evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Unqualified additional test station | High · output constraint | Supplier test engineering / before volume release | Validation results and witnessed repeat test |
| Unconfirmed key-component arrival | High · start-date uncertainty | Supplier purchasing / before schedule approval | Arrival evidence and verified material allocation |
| Work instruction does not match revision | High · assembly error risk | Supplier engineering / before pilot | Approved revision at point of use and operator briefing |
What accompanies the final report
Scope & evidence register
Product, site, date, records examined, observations and limitations.
Findings discussion
Explanation of material risks, unresolved questions and decision conditions.
Further site work, specialist tests and corrective-action verification are quoted or included according to the agreed scope.